I didnt intend to begin every reason with "The military...", it's just that when I think of everything that's going wrong, it all seems to start from there..
1)There are an estimated 8,000-10,000 people who have been put in jail by military tribunal AFTER Feb 11… More then Mubarak did in 30 years
2)Four people have been sentenced to death by military tribunal, for alleged rape,(including a minor, in contravention of Egyptian law)
3)Detainees who have been released report that they have been consistently mocked sexually abused, beaten and tortured. Many describe being tortured in the national museum. Human rights organizations' reports verify these testimonies.
4)The Military has arrested and tortured activists on Feb26, March 9th, April8/9th, and May15th, among other days
5)Military spokesmen have described those arrested from tahrir as “bultugeya”, or “thugs” despite the fact that some of them are known activists who were relatively prominent during Egypt’s revolution..
6)The military is reverting to the same rhetoric used by the Mubarak regime describing protesters, and anyone who causes them trouble as “foreign nationals”, “foreign agents”, “misled youth” etc….Just like Mubarak.
They’ve also taken to labeling those they arrest as remnants of the NDP, even if it makes no sense that that should be the case(recall the events of April 8/9th when Ibrahim Kamel was charged with causing the death of three protesters, before being quietly released almost one month later)
7)The military has outlawed protests, strikes and demonstrations…just like Mubarak did.
8) State newspapers are behaving exactly as they did pre-revolution, warning of the grave danger faced by the counry as a result of planned protests.Amazingly, this doesn't just extend to protests planned for the 27th. They've constantly made reference to impending,economic collapse—supposedly a consequence of "instability"— despite there being no evidence to suggest that the economy is anywhere near such a a state.
9)The military has written a law against “thuggery”- meaning that anybody can be arrested for any reason and described as a thug. (think about what it actually means to be a thug, or how one is defined, and it becomes apparent that it’s a catchall term that can be used to describe anybody the accuser wants to arrest)
10)The military has drawn a ‘red line’ around itself by ordering the press not to publish any stories or caricatures about it….just like Mubarak
11) The military has unilaterally issued numerous laws that do not address the most basic of the revolution's demands. Indeed, most of them defy the expectations and recommendations of respected political entities.
Finally, the military has demonstrated that it is unwilling to meet the revolution’s demands unless forced to do so by popular pressure (the resignation of Shafiq’s govt, the arrest of Mubarak & his family, the arrest of the big names associated with Mubarak like Sorour, Azmy and El-Sherif, changing the editors of state newspapers and TV & Radio)
UPDATE: The military have arrested numerous activists for distributing flyers encouraging people to demonstrate on Friday. As if there wasn't enough reason to head to the square already
Thursday, May 26, 2011
Sunday, May 15, 2011
The violence of April 8th/9th & Ibrahim Kamel's release
On april 8th and in the early hours of April 9th, a sit-in in Tahrir square, staged by a number of army officers along with a few hundred civlian demonstrators was violently broken up by the Egyptian army.
The army initially claimed that no one had been killed, before later admitting that one demonstrator, did in fact die in the violence.
Reuters revealed that ambulance sources listed at least two killed, while eyewitnesses report that many more were killed.
The Supreme Council of the Armed Forces (SCAF) blamed the violence on remnants of the old regime, posting a communiqué on Facebook only a few minutes after the end of it's operation, and announcing that it had apprehended Business tycoon and former NDP member Ibrahim Kamel.
While Kamel has been implicated in other cases, and is almost certainly guilty of at least a number of those charges—one example being what is referred to as the 'Camel incident'—it was instantly apparent to everyone present that night, that Kamel was being used as a scapegoat.
For the most part, local media organisations were either unwilling, or unable, to question the validity of the SCAF's version of events despite clear video evidence contradicting it.
This video, for example, clearly shows the army's initiation of the break-up against peaceful protesters:
Now, a little over a month later, Kamel has been quietly by released by the military prosecution for what it describes, unsurprisingly, as "a lack of evidence"
http://www.almasryalyoum.com/en/node/352347 [En]
The fact that his release has received such little attention is a worrying indicator about the current state of press accuracy and freedom in Egypt. Not to mention of course the Egyptian Military's conduct with demonstrators and honesty with the public.
The army initially claimed that no one had been killed, before later admitting that one demonstrator, did in fact die in the violence.
Reuters revealed that ambulance sources listed at least two killed, while eyewitnesses report that many more were killed.
The Supreme Council of the Armed Forces (SCAF) blamed the violence on remnants of the old regime, posting a communiqué on Facebook only a few minutes after the end of it's operation, and announcing that it had apprehended Business tycoon and former NDP member Ibrahim Kamel.
While Kamel has been implicated in other cases, and is almost certainly guilty of at least a number of those charges—one example being what is referred to as the 'Camel incident'—it was instantly apparent to everyone present that night, that Kamel was being used as a scapegoat.
For the most part, local media organisations were either unwilling, or unable, to question the validity of the SCAF's version of events despite clear video evidence contradicting it.
This video, for example, clearly shows the army's initiation of the break-up against peaceful protesters:
Now, a little over a month later, Kamel has been quietly by released by the military prosecution for what it describes, unsurprisingly, as "a lack of evidence"
http://www.almasryalyoum.com/en/node/352347 [En]
The fact that his release has received such little attention is a worrying indicator about the current state of press accuracy and freedom in Egypt. Not to mention of course the Egyptian Military's conduct with demonstrators and honesty with the public.
A full account of the night's events by the NYTimes is available here:
Monday, May 9, 2011
Imbaba violence
Some people blame the violence yesterday on former regime figures. Some, like the MB, insist that 'anonymous' forces want to spread sectarian strife in Egypt—whatever that means exactly.
Personally, it seems to me like the problem is:
a) a lax security situation (why this is still the case is a mystery, however)
b) That there are thousands of Salafis, or non-Salafi Muslims, who believe that the Coptic Church regularly kidnaps Christian converts to Islam and imprisons them in Churches.
Personally, it seems to me like the problem is:
a) a lax security situation (why this is still the case is a mystery, however)
b) That there are thousands of Salafis, or non-Salafi Muslims, who believe that the Coptic Church regularly kidnaps Christian converts to Islam and imprisons them in Churches.
Friday, May 6, 2011
Orientalising the Egyptian Revolution
This article, by Rabab al Mahdi, is really so good it deserves a post all it's own.
As you might have guessed from the title its about the narrative imposed on the Egyptian revolution by the west.
Really worth a read,but you'll have to copy and paste the web address below into your browser
http://allafrica.com/stories/201105060739.html
As you might have guessed from the title its about the narrative imposed on the Egyptian revolution by the west.
Really worth a read,but you'll have to copy and paste the web address below into your browser
http://allafrica.com/stories/201105060739.html
Just how bad is it in Syria?
Although the Syrian regime has received widespread condemnation for it's brutal crackdown on protesters, something of a media blackout has left world audiences unaware of the severity of the atrocities committed in cities like Deraa, Banyas and Homs.
Dramatic, professionally shot footage by international news organizations was a huge thorn in the side of the ousted Tunisian and Egyptian leaders—mobilizing world opinion against the regimes, and, in turn, putting pressure on world leaders to lend their support to demonstrators.
Unfortunately, this is not the case in Syria.
Bashar Al-Assad seems to have learned well from the mistakes of his ousted counterparts having expelled all foreign journalists before the calling in the army to lay siege to pro-democracy hotbeds.
As a result, grainy, amateur footage—most often recorded on mobile phones— is the only source of video evidence of the violence perpetrated by his Military, Security forces and armed loyalist gangs.
Furthermore, fighting with Libya for the limelight has meant that Arabs and Westerners alike, in general, seem relatively unmoved by the ongoing events in Syria. The result of that ofcourse, is that governments in the Middle East as well as the West, have more leeway to avoid pressuring Bashar's regime.
While human rights groups have reported violations ranging from the targeting of unarmed protests with live ammunition, to indiscriminate tank shelling of cities and villages and sweeping mass arrests, pro-democracy activists are struggling to get their message out in the way that those of Tunisia and Egypt were lucky enough to do.
The following is a collection of videos that graphically demonstrate the extent of the violence.
(Graphic)April 30th, Friday of Anger in the Village of Talbeesa.
This Syrian soldier explains how he defected after receiving orders to shoot civilians.(English Subtitles)
Busloads of security forces march into city of Deraa,to put down it's revolt.
Dramatic, professionally shot footage by international news organizations was a huge thorn in the side of the ousted Tunisian and Egyptian leaders—mobilizing world opinion against the regimes, and, in turn, putting pressure on world leaders to lend their support to demonstrators.
Unfortunately, this is not the case in Syria.
Bashar Al-Assad seems to have learned well from the mistakes of his ousted counterparts having expelled all foreign journalists before the calling in the army to lay siege to pro-democracy hotbeds.
As a result, grainy, amateur footage—most often recorded on mobile phones— is the only source of video evidence of the violence perpetrated by his Military, Security forces and armed loyalist gangs.
Furthermore, fighting with Libya for the limelight has meant that Arabs and Westerners alike, in general, seem relatively unmoved by the ongoing events in Syria. The result of that ofcourse, is that governments in the Middle East as well as the West, have more leeway to avoid pressuring Bashar's regime.
While human rights groups have reported violations ranging from the targeting of unarmed protests with live ammunition, to indiscriminate tank shelling of cities and villages and sweeping mass arrests, pro-democracy activists are struggling to get their message out in the way that those of Tunisia and Egypt were lucky enough to do.
The following is a collection of videos that graphically demonstrate the extent of the violence.
(Graphic)April 30th, Friday of Anger in the Village of Talbeesa.
This Syrian soldier explains how he defected after receiving orders to shoot civilians.(English Subtitles)
Busloads of security forces march into city of Deraa,to put down it's revolt.
Thursday, May 5, 2011
The Road to Egypt's Revolution (Documentary) [Ar]
This episode of the AlJazeera documentary program "Ta7t al-Mighar" (under the miscroscope) is a brilliantly directed, well researched and compelling look into the events that led to the ouster of former President Hosni Mubarak.
It weaves together dramatic footage of events starting in April 2008, with screen shots and narration of the social media discussions and online organization, highlighting the role played by the internet without overstating it.
A truly fascinating look into the workings of Egypt's online activist community and the work they did leading up the revolution.
Wednesday, May 4, 2011
Bahrain: What constitutes a plausible lie?
Bahraini authorities yesterday announced that they would charge a number of medical workers with the killing of two protesters.
This is the latest step in a far-reaching crackdown that the government has undertaken in response to the protests there. Basically, the bahraini government doesn't like having figures as credible as doctors and nurses out and about given what they've witnessed, so they've decided to arrest them.
Apparently, the Bahraini government is so bad at gauging what constitutes a plausible lie that they would have you believe that medical workers took the opportunity to go on a crime spree.
The article is full of the most ridiculous claims, including this little gem from the Minister of Justice:
"doctors inflicted additional wounds on a protester who arrived at SMC with a thigh wound, causing him to bleed to death."
Read the full article here:
http://www.dailystar.com.lb/May/04/Government-arrests-members-of-Al-Wefaq-in-broader-crackdown-on-opposition.ashx#axzz1LKlDrUv5
This is the latest step in a far-reaching crackdown that the government has undertaken in response to the protests there. Basically, the bahraini government doesn't like having figures as credible as doctors and nurses out and about given what they've witnessed, so they've decided to arrest them.
Apparently, the Bahraini government is so bad at gauging what constitutes a plausible lie that they would have you believe that medical workers took the opportunity to go on a crime spree.
The article is full of the most ridiculous claims, including this little gem from the Minister of Justice:
"doctors inflicted additional wounds on a protester who arrived at SMC with a thigh wound, causing him to bleed to death."
Read the full article here:
http://www.dailystar.com.lb/May/04/Government-arrests-members-of-Al-Wefaq-in-broader-crackdown-on-opposition.ashx#axzz1LKlDrUv5
Tuesday, May 3, 2011
Osama's Dead
Well, they finally did it..Osama Bin Laden is dead.
And it only took ten years, two wars, hundreds of thousands of lives and a couple of trillion dollars.
I would go over the details about where and how, but that's kind of pointless. For the last 48 hours its been the only news story carried by,well, everyone. The fact that all the news organisations have deemed that necessary is ridiculous and deserves a post of its own.
For now though, let me just say that his death is all but irrelevant given the "Arab Spring" and the marginalization Al-Qaida's experienced as a result (Apparently, Osama'd already been relegated to the role of a symbolic or spiritual leader for a few years now as a result of having to hide for his life)
Moving on... nobody could have been happier yesterday then Bashar Al-Assad, who took the opportunity to tighten the stranglehold on Deraa while everyone in the world was distracted...At least, thats what I gather he did from Syrian Twitter users. I guess we'll find out tomorrow, when news organizations around the world will hopefully regain their senses and get back to breaking stories of more immediate relevance—of which there are many to choose from..
Syria's bad luck notwithstanding, I was actually pretty glad to hear the news of Obama's death. Here's why:
1. Obama will find it infinitely easier to get re-elected next year. His government has done much that deserves criticsim, but the truth is that Obama is better for the middle east, and the world, then any Republican president. For that I am glad.
2.Al Qaida's now been dealt a severe blow. Im not the least bit upset about that, because AQ has been nothing but bad news for the middle east. Its pretty safe to say, for example, that Iraq would not have happened were it not for AQ's misguided attempts to punish the US for it's ME policies. That's not to say that Bush's government was justified in its invasion, it wasn't. In my mind, Bush and his neocon buddies are even bigger war criminals then Osama and deserve the same fate. Nevertheless, responsibility for the deaths of hundreds of thousands of innocent Iraqis lays partially in Osama and AQ's hands.
3. The 'Terrorism excuse'
Terrorism has always been a dirty word, but 9/11 elevated it to a status that immediately gave any government throwing it around incredible leverage against it's enemies, both foreign and domestic.
The US made vague claims about Saddam being in league with Al-Qaida as one of its many ridiculous justifications for invasion. Bush was reelected and ravaged the world for an addditional four years, partly as a consequence of Americans' overblown sense of fear at the prospect of terrorism.
Russia delighted in their newfound ability to operate with impunity against Chechen rebels by simply labeling them terrorists.
China justified all manner of authoritarian practices by using the same trick
Israel began to use the word terrorist instead of Palestinian, greatly damaging the image of the Palestinian cause in the American public's eyes. (Unfortunately for Palestine, the US public's perception of the conflict is one of the biggest obstacles to achieving statehood)
In short, terrorism became an excuse used by governments around the world, authoritarian and otherwise, to crack down on dissent or to push forward unpopular policies. With Osama's THE terrorist's death, the terrorism excuse will hopefully ring even more hollow then it always has.
And it only took ten years, two wars, hundreds of thousands of lives and a couple of trillion dollars.
I would go over the details about where and how, but that's kind of pointless. For the last 48 hours its been the only news story carried by,well, everyone. The fact that all the news organisations have deemed that necessary is ridiculous and deserves a post of its own.
For now though, let me just say that his death is all but irrelevant given the "Arab Spring" and the marginalization Al-Qaida's experienced as a result (Apparently, Osama'd already been relegated to the role of a symbolic or spiritual leader for a few years now as a result of having to hide for his life)
Moving on... nobody could have been happier yesterday then Bashar Al-Assad, who took the opportunity to tighten the stranglehold on Deraa while everyone in the world was distracted...At least, thats what I gather he did from Syrian Twitter users. I guess we'll find out tomorrow, when news organizations around the world will hopefully regain their senses and get back to breaking stories of more immediate relevance—of which there are many to choose from..
Syria's bad luck notwithstanding, I was actually pretty glad to hear the news of Obama's death. Here's why:
1. Obama will find it infinitely easier to get re-elected next year. His government has done much that deserves criticsim, but the truth is that Obama is better for the middle east, and the world, then any Republican president. For that I am glad.
2.Al Qaida's now been dealt a severe blow. Im not the least bit upset about that, because AQ has been nothing but bad news for the middle east. Its pretty safe to say, for example, that Iraq would not have happened were it not for AQ's misguided attempts to punish the US for it's ME policies. That's not to say that Bush's government was justified in its invasion, it wasn't. In my mind, Bush and his neocon buddies are even bigger war criminals then Osama and deserve the same fate. Nevertheless, responsibility for the deaths of hundreds of thousands of innocent Iraqis lays partially in Osama and AQ's hands.
3. The 'Terrorism excuse'
Terrorism has always been a dirty word, but 9/11 elevated it to a status that immediately gave any government throwing it around incredible leverage against it's enemies, both foreign and domestic.
The US made vague claims about Saddam being in league with Al-Qaida as one of its many ridiculous justifications for invasion. Bush was reelected and ravaged the world for an addditional four years, partly as a consequence of Americans' overblown sense of fear at the prospect of terrorism.
Russia delighted in their newfound ability to operate with impunity against Chechen rebels by simply labeling them terrorists.
China justified all manner of authoritarian practices by using the same trick
Israel began to use the word terrorist instead of Palestinian, greatly damaging the image of the Palestinian cause in the American public's eyes. (Unfortunately for Palestine, the US public's perception of the conflict is one of the biggest obstacles to achieving statehood)
In short, terrorism became an excuse used by governments around the world, authoritarian and otherwise, to crack down on dissent or to push forward unpopular policies. With Osama's THE terrorist's death, the terrorism excuse will hopefully ring even more hollow then it always has.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)